Letter Ballot seeking DICOM Standards Committee (DSC) approval of the Proposed DICOM Supplement: Supplement 206: CRYPTREC TLS Profile, October 18 Deadline

Hello DI Community,

A vote of abstention was registered with DICOM on behalf of the Canadian DI community.

Kind regards,
Raqia Hazam

Hello DI Community,

Please see this request for approval from DICOM regarding Supplement 206: CRYPTREC TLS Profile. Please submit your response by end of day October 18 2018 so I can comment on your behalf. If I don't receive any feedback by the deadline, Canada will abstain.

Thank you,




To:DICOM Standard Committee (DSC) Voting and Alternate Voting Members

Cc:Chair of WG-06 – Bjorn Nolte, Siemens Healthineers
DICOM Editor – David Clunie, PixelMed

From: DICOM Secretariat Office
Luiza Kowalczyk, Senior Operations DICOM Manager
Lisa Spellman, General DICOM Secretary

Subject: Letter Ballot seeking DICOM Standards Committee (DSC) approval of the Proposed DICOM Supplement: Supplement 206: CRYPTREC TLS Profile

Ballot opens: 2018-09-19 (12:00 USA Eastern Time)
Ballot closes: 2018-11-07 (12:00 USA Eastern Time)

Scope and Field of Application
Supplement 206 (reproduced from the document for convenience:)

This supplement adds a new Secure Connection profile to make DICOM consistent with the latest recommendations from the Japanese CRYPTREC committee. The CRYPTREC TLS Profile requires compliance with the IETF BCP 195 Recommendations for Secure Use of Transport Layer Security (TLS) and Datagram Transport Layer Security (DTLS) plus support for the additional cypher suites specified by the CRYPTREC committee. This profile requires that TLS negotiation start with the strong security protection parameters, and allows progressive negotiation of weaker protection down to a specified minimum protection limit. The CYPTREC committee has extended the BCP195 recommendation by adding cyphersuites that must be available for negotiation, and therefore a new profile beyond those in Supplement 204 is needed.

Who can vote? Only the designated Primary voting representatives of the DSC member organizations/companies are invited and entitled to vote. (Votes may also be submitted by the designated Alternate voting representatives, on behalf of the Primary representative.) (Others in the DICOM Community will receive a copy of this ballot as a courtesy so that all will be apprised of anticipated extensions to the DICOM Standard.)

Instructions for accessing the documents and submitting comments:

1.As noted above the DICOM Secretariat (MITA/NEMA) uses a third party software, KAVI, for the distribution of this Letter Ballot and collection of the responses and comments.
2.To access NEMA/KAVI: an ‘account’ has been set up and an individual password has been assigned by NEMA for all Primary and Alternate voting members of the DSC. Some members have already used this ‘account’ to access other NEMA workspaces. Others may not have used it or forgot the password. When clicking on the below links for the first time you will be prompted to enter your e-mail and password to gain access. If you do not know or forgot your password, click right-away on ‘forgot password’ and follow the instructions. If any problems, please contact the NEMA Webmaster This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. PLEASE BEAR WITH US TO COMPLETE THIS “ONE-TIME” STEP.
3. To Download document(s) to local drives: Click on the ‘Download’ links below to download the Word and/or PDF versions of the draft Supplement. If the Word and PDF versions differ, the PDF version governs. The access dialog box may appear; follow instructions in par. 2 above to log in/access.
4.Submit Votes/Comment(s):
Click on the ‘Vote/Comment’ link below. The access dialog box may appear; follow instructions in par. 2 above to log-in/access. Thereafter enter your vote. If you wish to comment (or must comment with a negative vote) the comment-submission-template appears. Please complete the mandatory fields. Generally do not check the ‘Notify all members….’ option in order to reduce e-mails but check the other two notify options.
Forms of comments:
• You may enter text, or attach a document containing your comments, or mark-up parts or the whole of the document and attach same.
• If your comments relate to several specific sections you can combine them in a single comment entry or make separate comment entries.

Your vote may be:
In the old ballots
• Approve options section of the form
• Approve with comments
• Disapprove (comments required)
• Abstain
• Abstain with comments.

In this new 'KAVT' ballot
• select “Affirmative” in the “Ballot
• select “Affirmative” and click on “Add Comment” in the “Comments” section
• select “Negative”- you must click on “Add Comment” and “Save” the comment
• Select "Abstain" as a “Ballot Option”
• select “Abstain” and click on “Add Comment” in the “Comments” section
Note:A negative vote should be accompanied by comment(s) on the particular paragraph or area with which the voter takes exception. The objections or concerns cannot be properly addressed without pertinent comments. (However, you do not need to cast a negative vote in order to comment.)

[END OF INSTRUCTIONS]
‘Download’ links:
Sup206_lb_ CRYPTREC_TLS_Profile- PDF Document:
standards.nema.org/higherlogic/ws/groups/300000557/download/23430/latest
Sup206_lb_ CRYPTREC_TLS_Profile-WORD Document:
standards.nema.org/higherlogic/ws/groups/300000557/download/23429/latest
Sup206_lb_ CRYPTREC_TLS_Profile-Overview PPT:
standards.nema.org/higherlogic/ws/groups/300000557/download/23431/latest

‘Vote/Comment’ link:
Sup 206 Official Ballot -
standards.nema.org/higherlogic/ws/groups/300000557/ballots/ballot?id=2314

Note: if you click on “Voting Summary by Interest Category” you will find a long list of categories and several data fields. Most of the categories are not relevant to DICOM and several data fields are not populated. Please disregard this page, at this time.